Friday Face Off: Ghostly boys

I'm really not sure where I first saw this cover for River Boy, but as soon as I saw it, I knew there was something it reminded me of -- Andrew Clements Things Not Seen.  Both are ghostly images of boys, facing right, with night skies behind them.  And though they're not the same boy or the same image, in other respects the resemblance is uncanny.  Not sure who did it first, but we can all decide who did it best...

What do you think?  Which makes you want to pick the book up?  

Who did it best?

Last Week on FFO:  She Smells the Dead smelled defeat when it went up against Ghost Town.  A lot of you did like She Smells the Dead (though not that horrific title), and some found Ghost Town chaotic, but most praised the flourishes and colors of Ghost Town.  Me personally, I think GT wins hands down.
The placement of the subject is much nicer, I love the fade and the flourishes, and the angle of the model is so much more flattering. And though the cover for She Smells is nicely done for the most part, it certainly does look a bit like "fun with photoshop."

Winner ------>